Abortion bans have fallen short of passage in two heavily Republican states, signaling more political turmoil for the GOP as it seeks to enact unpopular strict pro-life policies.
A handful of Republican state senators in both South Carolina and Nebraska defected from their party late Thursday to derail proposed near-total bans on abortion.
In South Carolina, all five of the chamber’s female lawmakers, including three Republicans, led a filibuster against the bill that would have banned abortion from conception.
Republican Sen. Sandy Senn criticized Majority Leader Shane Massey for repeatedly “taking us off a cliff on abortion” with the proposed ban that would have been one of the strictest ones in the nation.
“The only thing that we can do when you all, you men in the chamber, metaphorically keep slapping women by raising abortion again and again and again, is for us to slap you back with our words,” Senn said.
Halfway across the nation in Nebraska, it was a single male Republican lawmaker who torpedoed a bill to ban virtually all abortions from six weeks after conception.
Sen. Merv Riepe, a previous supporter, abstained from the bill after expressing concern that women might not know they were pregnant.
When he received pushback from fellow pro-life Republicans, Riepe warned his conservative colleagues to listen to women demanding a more flexible approach.
“We must embrace the future of reproductive rights,” Riepe said.
The twin defeats for pro-life forces signal that Republicans are likely to continue to struggle with the abortion issue after the Supreme Court’s unpopular decision last year to overturn Roe v. Wade.
The decision gave the green light for states to tighten restrictions on abortion as they see fit, opening the floodgates to ever-stricter laws in GOP-run states, where Republican lawmakers say life begins at conception and abortion is akin to murder.
But large majorities of Americans support abortion rights, even in red states, causing a major headache for the GOP with moderate Republicans and women seeking to tap the brakes on the crusade before it leads to more political setbacks.
A spreading fight over medication abortion has also raised the political temperature over abortion rights nationwide, in both red states and pro-choice strongholds like New York.
The Supreme Court last week placed a temporary hold on a conservative appeals court’s ban on sending the abortion drug mifepristone by mail and other restrictions.
Some Republican states have already banned use of medication abortion but if the ban is eventually upheld it would apply in blue states even though the top court last year said it intended to allow the states to decide the issue.
The crackdowns have energized women and pro-choice voters who had previously been complacent about the possibility of abortion rights being rolled back nationwide.
Some moderate Republicans in New York have refused to back the anti-abortion push, fearing a backlash at the polls in 2024.