Gwyneth Paltrow is appearing in a Park City, Utah, courtroom for a civil lawsuit over a 2016 skiing incident.
Paltrow, 50, is being sued by retired optometrist Terry Sanderson, who first filed a lawsuit against her back in January 2019, following a February 2016 incident where the two collided while skiing a beginner-level slope at Deer Valley Resort.
In Sanderson’s 2019 lawsuit, he accused Paltrow of colliding with him from behind while she skied with an instructor and also alleged the ski instructor filed a false report claiming Paltrow did not cause the accident at the time.
A rep for Paltrow told Mister Truth at the time: “This lawsuit is completely without merit. Anyone who reads the facts will realize that.” Paltrow also denied the allegations in a countersuit filed the next month, claiming that Sanderson was the one who hit her from behind and is now trying to “exploit her celebrity and wealth.”
Sanderson initially sued Paltrow for $3.1 million in 2019, but a judge later ruled he could only sue for $300,000 in damages. Meanwhile, the actress is countersuing for $1 and attorney fees.
Before a jury was sworn in on Tuesday, March 21, Judge Kent R. Holmberg ruled that the jury will not hear arguments concerning an alleged “hit-and-run,” as Dr. Sanderson claimed in his original 2019 lawsuit.
The judge said that he established, via evidence, that Paltrow had stopped and determined that Sanderson did not have any significant injuries before she and a ski instructor, who was with her at the time, left the scene of the incident.
Read on for some of the biggest revelations from the proceeding and check back for updates throughout the trial, which is expected to last about two weeks.
Both Paltrow and Sanderson claim they were the downhill skier
Opening statements kicked off with lawyers from both sides on March 21, describing the role Paltrow and Sanderson might have played during the incident. Ski etiquette was discussed at length, a key detail at the core of the case.
According to the sport’s rules, the person who is further down the mountain has the right of way. “All skiers know that when they’re skiing down the mountain, it’s their responsibility to yield the right of way to skiers below them,” Sanderson’s attorney Lawrence Buhler told jurors.
However, both sides claim they were the downhill skier. Paltrow’s lawyer, Stephen Owens, said that the actress was skiing when she suddenly saw “two skis appear between her skis and a man comes up right behind her,” adding that she thought she was being assaulted. Meanwhile, Buhler alleges that Paltrow “skied out of control” on the beginner’s run and into Sanderson’s back.
Paltrow’s team questions the amount of media surrounding the case
On day two of the trial, Paltrow’s attorneys voiced concerns over the amount of media members present outside the Park City court and whether cameras with live video feeds placed in the courtroom should be pointed directly at the Oscar-winning actress.
“We have a new camera pointed directly at my client, right there, on the right,” Paltrow’s attorney Stephen Owens said before proceedings began Wednesday, March 22. “And this has been a problem where, for instance, reporters being in front of my client’s car going out [Tuesday]. Cameras in her face, inches away.”
“I want to be advised if there are new changes, because it’s just by chance that we see there’s a camera pointed directly at her, which is contrary to the decorum order,” he added, after Judge Kent. R. Holmberg indicated the court was working on meeting the defense’s request.
Paltrow’s side says Sanderson’s ‘traumatic’ injuries are exaggerated
During the first two days of the trial, Sanderson’s attorneys argued that the retired optometrist sustained four broken ribs and a traumatic brain injury from the 2016 collision with Paltrow, after which he claims he was knocked unconscious for several minutes and did not know where he was when he regained consciousness.
“Gwyneth Paltrow skied out of control,” read the claim in the lawsuit, “knocking [Sanderson] down hard, knocking him out, and causing a brain injury, four broken ribs and other serious injuries. Paltrow got up, turned and skied away, leaving Sanderson stunned, lying in the snow, seriously injured.”
Paltrow’s attorneys, led by Owens, argued that Sanderson’s injury claims were exaggerated and cited his international travel to 10 countries in the years since the incident. They also argued that a neuroradiology expert, Dr. Wendell Gibby, hired by Sanderson’s attorneys did not review a 2009 MRI the plaintiff underwent years before the collision that showed the retired optometrist had sustained past brain injuries.
Gibby testified that he found it more likely that Sanderson “was struck from the left side and then hit the ground” based on the testimony of eyewitness Craig Ramon.
Paltrow was introducing her kids to then-boyfriend Brad Falchuk when the accident occurred
As Paltrow’s attorney Owens made his opening argument on March 21, he noted that her now-husband Brad Falchuk and his two children accompanied the Academy Award-winning actress and her daughter, Apple (now 18) and son Moses (now 16) to Deer Valley Resort for the Feb. 2016 skiing trip, where the incident occurred.
“And [Falchuk] has kids the exact same age as Gwyneth’s daughter and son,” Owens told the court, after describing that the trip “was a sentimental issue” for Paltrow as she wanted her children to learn to ski.
“And this was really their first trip to sort of a have a mixed, see-if-this-might-work,” Owens said. “So it was a special time and it was a lovely day.”
Paltrow’s lawyer says that Sanderson emailed his daughter ‘I’m famous’ after the crash
During Owen’s opening statement, he revealed that Sanderson emailed his daughter the same day of the crash to say, “I’m famous” — to which his daughter replied that she couldn’t believe “[the crash] was caught on GoPro,” (though he noted that the footage hasn’t been recovered).
Owens also argued that Sanderson became “obsessed with this lawsuit” and noted that he is “aging” (Sanderson is now 76 years old). He said that medical witnesses would point to pre-existing medical conditions Sanderson had before the collision took place.
Dr. Alina Fong (a neuropsychologist who treated Sanderson for the first time in May 2017) later claimed in a video deposition that her client had been “struggling with concussion symptoms for a year and a half” since the incident occurred.
She reported a “myriad of symptoms” that Sanderson had experienced, citing “mood and personality changes, pain as well as headaches.” She added that the incident has “affected him on so many levels” in reference to his personal life, family and relationships.